The car-buying experience is going through some major changes. Automakers are testing new ways to sell vehicles that shift power away from traditional dealerships, and the results could reshape where and how you buy your next car. If you’ve noticed prices getting more consistent or dealerships acting less like salespeople and more like helpful guides, you’re witnessing this shift in real time.
- Manufacturers like BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and Ford are moving toward agency models where they control pricing and inventory while dealers become service providers earning fixed commissions.
- Tesla’s direct-to-consumer approach has prompted legacy automakers to reconsider the century-old franchise system, though state laws still protect traditional dealerships in many regions.
- Dealerships are fighting back by upgrading their digital presence, focusing on customer service, and finding new revenue streams beyond vehicle sales.
The Traditional Model Is Getting a Makeover
For over a century, the dealership model worked pretty much the same way. Dealers bought cars from manufacturers, added their markup, and competed with each other on price. You’d walk into a showroom, negotiate for hours, and maybe walk out feeling like you got a good deal. But that system is starting to crack.
Automakers are tired of watching dealers undercut each other by an average of 12% below suggested retail prices. They want control over pricing, direct access to customer data, and the ability to sell cars the same way Apple sells iPhones. The agency model makes this possible. Under this setup, manufacturers own the inventory and set fixed prices. Dealerships become intermediaries who handle sales and earn a commission instead of a markup.
Mercedes-Benz announced plans to cut 10% of its global dealership network by 2025 as part of this transition. BMW is rolling out agency sales across Europe. Even Ford and General Motors are experimenting with direct sales for their electric vehicle lines. The message is clear: the old way of doing business is on its way out.
Why Manufacturers Want to Cut Out the Middleman
Follow the money, and you’ll understand why automakers love this idea. When they sell directly to consumers, they capture higher margins because there’s no dealer markup eating into profits. They also get customer data that used to stay with the dealership. That information helps them build better relationships with buyers and make smarter decisions about what to build next.
Online sales cost less than traditional dealership transactions. During the pandemic, manufacturers saw millions of people shopping for cars from their couches, and they realized the digital channel worked. Why maintain massive inventories at thousands of locations when customers will order online and wait a few weeks for delivery?
The shift also solves a pricing problem. Walk into three different dealerships for the same car, and you might get three wildly different prices. That inconsistency frustrates buyers who feel like they’re playing a guessing game. Fixed pricing removes the stress of negotiation and creates a more transparent buying experience.
Dealers Aren’t Going Down Without a Fight
Dealerships have serious advantages that online-only models can’t match. They provide local service centers, test drives, and face-to-face support. When your car breaks down, you need a real place to take it, and manufacturers don’t want to build that infrastructure from scratch.
Smart dealers are adapting fast. They’re investing in better websites where customers can browse inventory, configure vehicles, and complete most of the paperwork before stepping foot in the showroom. Places like a Dayton dealership and others are reimagining their spaces as community hubs rather than high-pressure sales floors. Subaru recently unveiled its Connection Hub concept, which includes outdoor green spaces, interactive displays, and areas for local events.
Many dealerships are also diversifying their revenue. Service departments, extended warranties, and parts sales are becoming bigger profit centers. Some are adding subscription services or partnering with local businesses to create additional income streams. The goal is to stay important even if new car sales generate smaller margins.
What This Means for You as a Buyer
The changes benefit consumers in some ways and complicate things in others. Fixed pricing means you won’t waste hours haggling, and you’ll know everyone pays the same amount. That’s a win for transparency. Online purchasing tools let you complete most of the transaction from home, saving time.
But you’ll also lose some flexibility. No more playing dealers against each other to get a better deal. No more last-minute negotiations that shave $2,000 off the sticker price. And if you live in a state with strong franchise laws, you might not see these changes for years. States like Texas have fought hard to keep Tesla from selling directly to consumers, and those legal battles could slow the transition.
The hybrid model seems most likely to win. You’ll probably see manufacturers handle pricing and inventory while dealerships focus on delivery, service, and the human touch that technology can’t replace. Research suggests this middle ground could actually be the most cost-effective approach, saving about $200 per vehicle compared to pure direct-to-consumer models.
What Comes Next
The automotive retail world won’t change overnight. State franchise laws protect dealerships in many regions, and changing those regulations takes time. Some manufacturers will move faster than others. Electric vehicle brands will likely adopt direct sales more aggressively since they don’t have decades of existing dealer relationships to protect.
For traditional dealers, survival means getting creative. The ones that invest in technology, focus on customer experience, and find ways to stay relevant beyond just selling cars will do well. The ones that cling to the old model will struggle. Consumers should expect more consistent pricing, better online tools, and a buying process that feels less like a negotiation and more like a normal retail transaction. The century-old dance between manufacturers and dealers is changing steps, and we’re all learning the new routine together.
This post may contain affiliate links. Meaning a commission is given should you decide to make a purchase through these links, at no cost to you. All products shown are researched and tested to give an accurate review for you.